“Computers and society” – this is the title of the class I’ve enrolled in this semester that is the driving incentive behind this blog that you are currently reading. If my subpar klout score is any indication, you already knew this as someone else affiliated with the course. Initially, though I didn’t realize it at the time, I did not interpret the title of the course as pertaining to a topic that is so very relevant to our modern everyday lives. In fact, it wasn’t until later in the course that I realized just how interesting a concept it is – in the unit that first mentioned the social media site known as Reddit.
Having made frequent use of this website over the past two or three years, I was surprised that it took me so long to realize that Reddit was such an interesting application of a large proportion of the concepts discussed throughout the units of this course. Not only does Reddit demonstrate many of the issues raised in a society driven by rapidly evolving computer based technology, but the site itself is a virtual society, subject to cultural and societal diversities, opportunities, and issues both comparable and unique to real-world concepts.
The intention of this blog entry is to outline how Reddit applies the concepts that have been raised within the content of this course, and explore several relevant extensions of the course material. I’ll provide a brief introduction to Reddit, in case you happen to be unfamiliar, but I highly recommend a quick visit in order to get a feel for the setup of the site – of course, if you ARE new to the site, be warned – the consequent development of chronic procrastination habits is almost inevitable.
Reddit’s main formula is simple and surprisingly effective. Users submit links to pictures, videos, news articles, blog entries, or just about any other webpage that can be conceived. The links are then viewed by other users, who have the option to “upvote” or “downvote” the submission, according to its relevancy to the designated subreddit. Posts are then displayed according to how they rank in terms of net upvotes and time of submission, allowing popular posts to be cycled throughout the day for consistently fresh content. Users also have the option to comment on posts with relevant or entertaining responses, which are then also subject to a similar upvote/downvote system. “Karma” as it is called is a user’s aggregate score of net upvotes versus downvotes, displayed both for ordinary submissions and comments by a given user.
On paper, the formula is fairly straightforward, but there are certainly intricacies to the post-sorting algorithm that affect just what ends up on the “front page” of Reddit – the rotating list of posts that are first viewed when one travels to Reddit. These small sorting rules are withheld from the general user base of Reddit, imposing an element of cautious suspicion on that which is delivered to the casual reader under the banner of most popular.
Consider Digg – a website with a similar concept and voting system. In 2010, it was discovered that users of the site were able to manipulate the voting system in order to promote submissions pertaining to certain biases while subsequently hiding those submissions that offered direct opposition. This included, but was not limited to, submissions with an advertisement incentive. This controversy essentially destroyed Digg, resulting in a mass exodus of users. While advertisement based submissions are allowed on Reddit, they are clearly marked as such so that users may view or ignore these posts at their discretion. Should a similar controversy ever arise, it is likely that Reddit would see many regular users abandon the site in search of a new forum with a promise of an uncorrupt submission system.
So what happens when a website is essentially run by a vast collection of individuals shrouded in anonymity? One effect of Reddit’s system is referred to as “the hivemind”. Certain patterns and recurring themes, phrases, or content seem to unfold through submissions and comment threads around the most popular subreddits, occasionally leading to a sort of virtual mob psychology. This effect has led to a share of controversial incidents. In one such instance, users banded together in order to thwart what was believed to be a fake charity scam, resulting in the mass boycotting of an actual charitable incentive. What began as a poorly researched theory that the individuals behind the charity were up to no good quickly escalated to full-scale internet bullying, up to and including death threats to those involved. Luckily, the hivemind was able to atone for its actions by supporting the charity following the realization of its error.

The hivemind effect is also found in bees, but they tend to be less likely to boycott initiatives or organizations
This is just one instance of many initiatives that are formed within the various communities of Reddit, and only one example of the kind of initiative one could subscribe to. For example, Reddit plays host to an endless stream of subreddits where users can share their creative endeavours and discoveries. In an interesting take on the controversy surrounding music sharing, readers of “Listen to this” have the option to post links to obscure or relatively unknown songs by artists of various popularity. Similarly, “Radio Reddit” is a subreddit where users can submit their own musical creations, allowing talented aspiring or armchair musicians a venue for their songs to be enjoyed and discussed. And of course, it doesn’t stop there – just about every creative hobby is covered, from the massively popular “Pics” subreddit that allows the sharing of visual art and photography, to the somewhat more obscure “No Sleep”, where users can share true or fabricated stories designed to frighten readers.
But Reddit offers more than just venues for the sharing of one’s work, creations, or opinions. Various subreddits exist with the sole intention of a somewhat unconventional form of education. “DIY” is a subreddit that allows users to submit instructions for common (or uncommon) projects. “Ask Science” is a forum for users to submit or respond to scientific queries, and is one of a multitude of “Ask” subreddits that encourage a similar format for various other topics.
Users of Reddit have seemingly endless options when it comes to education – but just like anywhere else on the internet, there’s just as much opportunity for misinformation as there is for correct information. The Karma system is meant to alleviate some of the pressure of this concern, as savvy users are often able to spot and prevent posts containing incorrect or controversial information from gaining too much popularity. Once again, this leaves the user to question just how free from manipulation the “Reddit algorithm” actually is, though an appropriate amount of caution is usually enough to sift through the nonsense and hit the quality posts.
And that’s just the thing – if one means to approach Reddit seeking quality information, it can’t be done blindly. Perhaps one of the most important concepts taught through the Computers and Society course was that of information quality. An important aspect of each assignment was to outline the source of the material being presented, and analyze why it was or wasn’t considered to be credible. And while top posts on Reddit are usually there for a reason, that reason is because the majority of users who have accessed the post agree with it. There’s no rule stating that the hivemind has to be correct or considerate when selecting the posts that are elevated to the front page at the end of the day –just like middle school student council elections, it’s all a matter of popularity.
This is where the key criticism of Reddit is aimed. The largest demographic of Reddit users appears to be liberal minded college students, and it’s not uncommon for people deviating from this accepted framework of beliefs and ideals to be ostracized, dismissed, or downright abused for their presence on the site. The thing is, no post on Reddit can ever be considered to be truly unbiased – until the entire world endorses and frequents the site (and even then), there will most likely always be a key demographic running the show, selecting the most popular submissions, and keeping the opposition’s submission at bay.
While the wonders of an online community such as Reddit are vast and easily accessible, it’s clear that caution will always need to be applied in order to achieve a generally positive experience from such a website. The free exchange of information is subject to all manner of corrupt, unpleasant, and controversial issues, but if one has the resources, the knowledge, and the willingness to be wary of them, then the true power of the internet is available – education, entertainment, communication, and so much more.
Not to mention a never-ending photo album of cats doing entertaining things.
Sources
http://news.cnet.com/8301-13924_3-20013668-64.html
http://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2012/11/02/mob-psychology/



